Spikes Vs. Spikeless Golf Shoes: What Should You Choose?

Golf shoes are among the most important factors to consider when golfers want to upgrade their gear. Spikes vs. spikeless golf shoes, what should they choose?

The main difference between these items is the design, as their names imply. Different designs lead to differences in traction, versatility, and other aspects.

This article will compare and contrast the two types of footwear in detail. Let’s read through and choose the winner! 


Differences Between Spikes Vs. Spikeless Golf Shoes 

The spikeless shoes feature a rubber base and design that will aid golfers in maintaining their balance while playing a game. 

The rubber cleats on the bottom of the spiked shoes provide extra ground contact. They offer more grip and assist golfers in keeping their balance.

Both items shine out in certain terms. Let’s check one by one and determine which you should get. 

1. Traction

Traction is the most apparent difference between the two items, splitting golfers’ opinions about them into two sides. 

Spiked footwear has a basic cleated style that helps you stay balanced. Since most courses have banned metal cleats because they can harm greens, most cleats are now softer.

The way replaceable claws contact the ground throughout the golf swing offers greater lateral stability.

On the other hand, spikeless traction has come a very long way. Rubber nubs are popular. You can also look for additional features. 

For example, the TPU outsole of Tri-Fi Grip from ECCO provides a high level of rotation, durability, and stability. 

You may also like the Articulated Integrated Traction from NIKE, which uses a fin-like design to grip the ground.

When playing in rainy conditions, the difference in traction becomes more noticeable. On the wet ground, spiked shoes give significantly greater traction. 

You can learn how the spikes affect your game from this video:

2. Comfort

Footwear without spikes certainly offers an advantage in comfort, even if the latest advancements have made it a minor one.

These models do not have the insert system or plastic cleats, so they are lighter.

This feature also eliminates the extra pressure areas where your foot rests on a spiked shoe’s spikes.

Thanks to innovations such as cushioning and lighter materials, spikes are more comfortable than ever. 

Although the difference is minimal, if you like the comfort of footwear that is similar to your favorite trainers, spiked sneakers may not be a good choice.

Shoes without cleats are more comfortable

3. Durability

The bottoms of your footwear wear out as you walk, no matter what you wear them for. Durability also separates footwear with and without cleats.   

Replacement cleats wear out quickly in spiky shoes. When they start losing their grip, you’ll sense a difference. 

The good news is that with the right replacement cleats and a cleat wrench, you can quickly gain a like-new grip with a simple replacement of cleats.

As long as you take care of the rest of your footwear properly, it can last quite long on the grass. 

Despite the durable materials, spikeless items can’t work for that long. Once they start to wear down, they lose grip and can’t perform as well as they used to.  

On the bright side, even when your footwear loses its traction, you can still use it off the course. 

The cleats are replaceable

4. Versatility

Spikeless shoes definitely excel in this situation. You can use them in many situations, such as driving to the course, stopping off to do some errands, and playing around without changing your footwear. 

Some golfers use such footwear when they are not on the green. If you buy a fashionable item, you can even wear it to your office or for a hangout. 

On the other hand, the footwear with cleats is for golf only. Golfers are still willing to give up versatility for the cleats’ longevity and tractions. 

You can wear spikeless footwear when off the course

5. Fit

Although the traction system has little impact on fit, your footwear needs to fit nicely. It would be best to measure your shoe size when wearing socks to get the accurate size. 

Golfers can also benefit from modern footwear but try to focus on how your footwear wears down and where the foot rubs. 

If your foot rubs against the toe box, a shoe with a bigger last or overall width will give you more space in the front.

If the shoe wears down inside, you may need arch support. On the other hand, you should find flexible footwear if it wears down outside. 

6. Style

Spikeless shoes are more fashionable and boast a trainer-like impression, whereas spiked shoes seem out of place when not on the course.

Spikeless shoes are perfect for wearing after a round of golf for not looking too golf-crazed.

Many golfers prefer spikeless items because they are a cooler alternative. However, the style depends mostly on your preference. 

Before you buy a pair of shoes, make sure to try them on and walk around in them. It’s meaningless to buy them if you feel uncomfortable, no matter how awesome they look. 

7. Waterproofness

To some extent, both of these items are waterproof golf shoes. While the fabric of spikeless models is more water-resistant, the ones with spikes are fully waterproof with a one- to a two-year warranty. 

8. Breathability

Spikeless shoes are better for breathability if you golf in hot, dry conditions. The material for these items is light, thin, and breathable, wicking away sweat on your feet. 

9. Cost

Although you can find both models with a price of lower than $80, the leather straps and more defined soles make spiky shoes a little more costly. 

Spikeless models may cost about $200 for premium versions, while the ones with spikes can cost up to $300 if you want to. 

10. Comparison

We have compared the two types of footwear in crucial factors. Now, it’s time to summarize their differences.

CriteriaSpiked shoesSpikeless shoes 
TractionExcellentModerate 
ComfortModerateExcellent 
DurabilityExcellentModerate 
VersatilityNot versatileHighly versatile 
FitAdjustable Adjustable 
StyleDepending on your taste Depending on your taste 
WaterproofnessGoodGood
BreathabilityModerateGood
CostMore expensiveCheaper 

Pros And Cons Of Spikes And Spikeless Golf Shoes 

So now the differences between the two items are clear. If you can’t still make up your mind, please check the pros and cons of each footwear below.

Spiked shoes

Pros:

  • Excellent traction
  • Durable
  • An ideal choice for various terrains

Cons:

  • Only suitable for golf
  • Not as comfortable as the others

Spikeless shoes

Pros:

  • Suitable for different purposes
  • Inexpensive
  • Breathable

Cons:

  • Less traction
  • Quick to wear down

Final Verdict: What Should You Choose? 

The real winner depends on your personal preference. You can consider the factors we discussed in this article before deciding.

If you need extra traction, spiked shoes are the way to go. If versatility is crucial, look for spikeless models so that you can wear them everywhere.

Hopefully, the guide we have shared can help you choose the best gear and maximize your performance. If you have any questions, please feel free to ask or refer to our tutorials.

Thank you for reading! 

Rate this post

Leave a Comment